Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent is betting billions that financial engineering can cool an overheating energy market, but analysts warn his “paper” intervention may trigger a chaotic “whipsaw” for global investors.

The Macro Gamble

As the conflict with Iran paralyzes the Strait of Hormuz, the U.S. Treasury is expected to announce an unprecedented measure to combat rising prices: shorting the oil futures market, as per a Reuters report.

The move reflects the “global macro” DNA of Secretary Bessent, a former Soros protégé, who is now attempting to use the Exchange Stabilization Fund to suppress a 21% surge in crude prices.

However, the strategy is meeting immediate skepticism from market veterans. Kevin Green, Senior Markets Correspondent at Schwab, labeled the move a potential “disconnect” from reality.

“This is hands down the biggest story of the day if the Treasury is about to start shorting futures to suppress prices,” Green noted. He warned the tactic would have “no real impact on the physical market” and could actually make conditions “worse for the physical market” by masking the true cost of the supply shortage.

Whipsaw Risk for Funds

While the Treasury aims for price stability, the intervention puts Washington on a collision course with Managed Futures funds. According to Michael McClain, an Alternative Investment Research Analyst at LPL Financial, these trend-following strategies are currently positioned with “long exposure across crude oil,” betting on the very price increases Bessent is trying to stop.

The danger for these investors is a violent market reversal. McClain warned that if government intervention disrupts established price trends, “signals will be whipsawed and constantly reversing—one of the worst possible environments for the industry.”

Physical Vs. Financial

The fundamental tension remains whether “paper” trades can solve a “physical” blockade. While the national average for gasoline has spiked, President Donald Trump remained firm on the military priority, stating, “They’ll drop very rapidly when this is over.”

Until then, Bessent's billion-dollar bet remains a high-stakes experiment in whether a hedge fund playbook can neutralize a geopolitical war.

Price Action In Oil

WTI Crude oil futures were trading lower in the early New York session by 0.53% to hover around $80.58 per barrel. The current price represents a 20.23% jump from Feb. 27, after the Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei was killed in air strikes in Iran.

The United States Oil Fund LP (NYSE:USO) tracking WTI has risen by 20.73% over the last five sessions, and 38.10% year-to-date.

Disclaimer: This content was partially produced with the help of AI tools and was reviewed and published by Benzinga editors.

Photo courtesy: Shutterstock