Anthropic’s soaring private-market valuation may say as much about the scarcity of its shares and the broader frenzy around artificial intelligence as it does about the company’s underlying fundamentals, Coin Bureau founder and cross-asset analyst Nic Puckrin told Benzinga.
A Series H funding round in May valued Anthropic at $965 billion. Secondary-market transactions have reportedly pushed its implied valuation even higher. Estimates currently range from roughly $1.05 trillion to $1.5 trillion.
Puckrin questioned whether those secondary-market prices necessarily represent what investors would ultimately be willing to pay for Anthropic once it goes public. It’s akin to SpaceX (NASDAQ:SPCX); Limited share supply can drive private-market valuations for highly sought-after companies more than a fundamental reassessment of the business.
"In a similar fashion to SpaceX, the pre-IPO valuation is driven more by scarcity than fundamentals," Puckrin said.
With existing shareholders reluctant to sell and investors eager for exposure to one of the leading AI companies, limited share availability can push secondary-market prices higher. But that does not necessarily mean public-market investors will value Anthropic 25% to 50% above its latest funding round.
Betting On IPO-Day Momentum
Puckrin said the current premium looks more like a bet on IPO-day momentum than a definitive signal of Anthropic’s long-term value.
That distinction could matter more after Anthropic lists publicly. While the company’s strong revenue growth supports a higher valuation, Puckrin said the real test of investor conviction will come after the initial public offering, when the stock begins trading with greater liquidity and faces broader public-market scrutiny.
"The weeks and months after the IPO will show what investors are really willing to pay for Anthropic," he said.
Puckrin also stopped short of comparing Anthropic’s valuation with the dot-com bubble, noting that the company has experienced rapid revenue growth. However, he questioned whether strong growth alone is enough to justify the increasingly elevated valuations being assigned to AI companies.
Nvidia Raises Broader AI Valuation Questions
His concerns extend beyond Anthropic to the financing ecosystem surrounding the AI boom.
Puckrin pointed to Nvidia’s partnerships with BlackRock and financing for companies purchasing Nvidia chips, arguing that such arrangements raise questions about whether capital is circulating through the AI ecosystem in ways that can reinforce valuations.
"What also makes me doubt the valuation numbers is the circular financing that appears to be propping up AI valuations, not only for Anthropic," Puckrin said.
For Anthropic, that leaves investors weighing whether its rising private-market valuation reflects its business economics or the enormous amount of capital chasing exposure to AI. If scarcity and expectations for IPO-day gains are doing much of the work, Anthropic could face a tougher valuation test once its shares begin trading publicly.
Photo: RixAiArt / Shutterstock – ek
Login to comment